• OBJECTION!@lemmy.ml
    link
    fedilink
    arrow-up
    3
    arrow-down
    1
    ·
    1 day ago

    “I live in the US.” That explains a lot about your inexperience about the nature of China and Russia.

    Lmao! Your script is amazing. If I was from China, obviously, you’d accuse me of being a paid actor. If I say I’m from the US, then, without skipping a beat, you’re accusing me of being “inexperienced” with those countries! No matter what my life experience, you always have a way to discredit me.

    Let me guess, your script now makes you tell me that you have traveled to China and everything was rosy.

    No, I have not. Nor do I need to. The burden on evidence is on the person making the claim. I can safely reject this conspiracy theory about “slave labor camps” just as I can reject any other baseless claim, as per Russell’s Teapot.

    Also, whataboutism works like this: A claims B does Bad Thing, then B says A does Bad Thing too. I started by saying both A and B do Bad Thing,

    No, I started this conversation by saying B does Bad Thing, then you said that A does Bad Thing too. That exactly fits your own definition for whataboutism. Get fucked, lol.

    Then you said ahhha, but what about ICE.

    Lol, now you’re just obviously acting in bad faith. I brought up ICE after the accusation of whataboutism, so you don’t get to use that to justify the claim. Also, the context in which I brought up was simply showing how your conspiratorial “logic” leads to absurd conclusions, like that Switzerland has secret slave labor camps that they’re just hiding really well. It was not to show that “the US has slave labor camps just like China,” but to demonstrate that baseless claims can be made about any country, once you remove any notion of grounding them in evidence.


    When you ground your ideas in evidence, and you actually examine the historical evidence, the idea that China is doing anything remotely close to 19th century colonial practices is absurd. It’s only when you don’t do those, and also act in bad faith, twisting around logic in absurd ways, and set impossible conditions where you’re damned if you do, damned if you don’t, only then can you “justify” your positions. In reality, you take those positions not because they are reasonable, but in order to defend the West’s historical record as much as you think you can get away with.

    • mefisdo_dot_info@lemmy.ca
      link
      fedilink
      arrow-up
      1
      arrow-down
      2
      ·
      1 day ago

      “China is doing anything remotely close to 19th century colonial practices” Actually, why do you compare today’s CCP to the 19th century actions of some Western kings? Why don’t you compare those actions to Mao’s actions then? Or to some Qing dynasty massacres? “China” is an ethnic mishmash that happens to cover contiguous land; still it is an empire that practices near-colonialism. Just like Russia does. Just like Habsburg Austria did. “Colonialism” doesn’t only apply to cases where the conquerors come by ship.

      Today’s China shows a more civilized outward face, but that is true for the Western countries too. No Belgian king has chopped anyone’s hand for a long time. In an apples to apples comparison, contemporary China is at least as bad, as the contemporary West.

      Oh, and just because you went there: fuck you too, tankie. Your ilk’s obsession with history is the only straw you can cling to.

      • OBJECTION!@lemmy.ml
        link
        fedilink
        arrow-up
        2
        arrow-down
        1
        ·
        1 day ago

        Actually, why do you compare today’s CCP to the 19th century actions of some Western kings?

        I do not. You did. You are the one who specifically brought up 19th century colonial practices. I have merely been responding to that.

        Yet one more instance of using blatant bad faith, as you dronies always do.