Why does one branch sometimes make a big deal out of a document, while another branch doesn’t even ask for it? Is it a matter of interpretation, employee discretion, or something else?

Institutions aren’t monoliths. Different offices and even different divisions in the same office have wildly different corporate cultures.
Uh… what type of institution are you referring to here?
Oh yeah patients ask this all the time. It’s all of the above plus the barometric pressure, whether or not it’s a holiday, whether or not the employees have gotten a raise lately or their boss just got replaced with an asshole or if the regulatory agency is coming this week, or if the printer is broken and so on and so forth into infinity. Studies show that across the board between numerous judges with OR without any number of other biases, you’re more likely to get a harsher sentence just before the judge has had lunch than just after. Life just has too many moving parts for things to stay consistent. At a certain point you have to make the decision to either roll with it or waste a bunch of energy being mad about it all the time. A lot of people also make things even worse for themselves by just constantly being shitty with everyone around them over it, so they don’t even get the nice things that you can occasionally get by being nice. Sometimes people even lose the ability to perceive when someone is genuinely trying to help them and wind up refusing it.
Managers might use whatever discretion they are allowed to impose additional restrictions or relax them. Chances are someone is operating in gray area there.
An organisation is not a monolith. Different organisations will have different structures. e.g. McDonalds is really oppressive with forcing branches to stick to very strict criteria, so you’ll see pretty much the same systems in any branch.
Most organisations come down to the people running things and delivering services locally. Having policies doesn’t guarantee that’s what’s done. Implementation is very variable in most industries/companies/organisations.
This is why you can get so much milage out of sweet talking and being nice to people or using contacts to just get stuff done (aside from what the rules say).
Because people are people and sometimes they just don’t give a fuck anymore.
Some are independently owned, so may have discretion.



