🏳️‍🌈 hi there, i’m blake! i’m a silly gay bear 🌀

  • 0 Posts
  • 51 Comments
Joined 1 year ago
cake
Cake day: February 25th, 2025

help-circle




  • Thanks for the quick and thoughtful reply, I appreciate it! I’m interested in discussing this further, I’ll reply inline, if I don’t mention something you may assume that I agree with you or that I’m happy to concede the point for the sake of discussion

    If you can’t get what you want without an animal, then definitionally you need to exploit the animal to get what you want.

    I disagree with that - for example, I think you’d agree that birdwatching isn’t exploitative, right? For me, exploitation is when you put your own needs/wants before the needs/wants of an animal. Just simply gaining some benefit from an interaction with an animal isn’t necessarily exploitative - though it certainly can be, and often is.

    To your broader point, it sounds to me like you’re kind of scared of yourself, like you don’t trust your own abilities to discern right from wrong. I completely understand that perspective, because I have issues with feeling that way about myself sometimes too.

    Your points about emotion clouding our judgment and not necessarily always putting the interests of the animal before our own is well made, but it kind of assumes that the staff at the animal shelter would be somehow more resistant to this issue. It’s like you’re offloading the ethical burden of having to make decisions for an animal’s wellbeing to someone else and assuming that they’ll handle it better than you will - an assumption which, frankly, is probably wrong.

    I get the vibe that you want to live as closely aligned with your values as possible, which results in a kind of pathological avoidance of responsibility - we can’t get it wrong/make a mistake if we just choose not to take any action.

    But the reality is that, as vegans, we’re far better than average at being able to provide a loving, caring home for animals than most. Shelters have limited space, staffing and resources, and while I agree from a utilitarian perspective that the money you’d spend on housing one animal would do more good if it was allocated to shelters, it doesn’t make the selfish choice inherently exploitative, I don’t think.

    Anyways, not criticising you at all, I trust you know what’s best for you, but I’m still very skeptical that acting as a guardian for an animal is inherently non-vegan.


  • Technically, it could be copyright infringement, depending on the work, a fair use exemption might apply - for example a screenshot from a game would be less likely to be infringing compared to, say, a painting due to less of the copyrighted work being reproduced and the avatar not being a replacement for the original work (i.e. seeing the screenshot wouldn’t give you the same experience as playing the game)

    In practice, I doubt very much anyone would ever actually even go so far as to send a cease and desist unless you were impersonating some brand or causing reputational damage.

    Morally speaking, I think it’s absolutely fine! People have been using copyrighted works in their avatars and signatures (remember those?!) since dial-up was fast enough to cope with it. If someone asks you not to then you should respect that but otherwise I’d say go ahead!


  • Can you explain a bit about why you think being a caretaker/guardian for an animal, is inherently exploitative?

    I would say that if you pay to buy an animal, that’s exploitative and harmful, but I don’t see the exploitation in, say, adopting a dog from an animal shelter - the dog is not harmed by that in any way, it is an improvement to the lives of the dog and the human, no? what am I missing?

    (vegan btw)